A good performance appraisal process should be able to answer three questions: What did the employee contribute? What could they have done better? And what support or opportunities will help them progress?

Are Performance Appraisals Measuring Real Performance?

Performance appraisal is one of those workplace processes that brings a different set of emotions for everyone involved.

 

For an employee, it is often a time to look back at the year gone by. There is a natural tendency to revisit the work they have done, the targets they have achieved, the challenges they have handled and the responsibilities they may have taken on beyond their role. Alongside that reflection comes uncertainty about how their contribution has been perceived and what the final assessment might look like.

 

For an employer or manager, the process involves looking at performance across an entire team. Each individual brings different responsibilities, strengths, challenges and expectations. Managers have to assess results, recognise contributions, address areas that need improvement, have difficult conversations and, at times, make decisions that can influence an employee’s career.

 

Having worked across both people management and organisational leadership, I believe this is where performance appraisals need closer attention. While employees want their efforts to be understood and fairly recognised, organisations need a reliable way to assess performance, maintain accountability and connect individual contributions with business priorities.

 

Both expectations are valid. However, the challenge lies in ensuring that the evaluation reflects more than what appears on a performance sheet. Meeting targets is important, but so are the circumstances in which those targets were achieved, the quality of work, ownership, collaboration and the ability to respond when priorities change.

 

This makes me question whether our current appraisal practices are capturing the complete picture of an employee’s performance, or only the parts that are easiest to measure.

 

When Targets Do Not Tell the Whole Story

Most organisations rely on clearly defined goals and key performance indicators to evaluate employees. These provide direction, establish accountability and help managers assess whether expected outcomes have been achieved. Without measurable expectations, performance evaluation can become subjective and difficult to apply consistently.

 

However, targets are only useful when viewed in the context in which they were set and achieved.

 

Consider a salesperson who falls short of a quarterly target because a few major deals are delayed by customer approvals. During the same period, they may have strengthened relationships with key accounts and built a pipeline that could contribute to future business. This contribution matters, but it should not automatically excuse a missed target. Managers must understand both the reasons behind the shortfall and the employee’s efforts to address it.

 

A similar situation can arise in marketing. A campaign may generate fewer leads than expected but improve audience quality, reduce acquisition costs or provide insights that help shape future campaigns. Looking only at lead volume would overlook these outcomes. At the same time, the evaluation must establish whether the campaign achieved its intended objectives.

 

In engineering, an employee may complete fewer tasks than a colleague because they have spent time resolving a complex technical issue or improving system stability. Their output may appear lower on a task-completion report, but the work may have prevented a larger operational problem.

 

In each case, the numbers tell part of the story, but not all of it.

 

This does not mean that effort should automatically be treated as achievement or that measurable outcomes should be ignored. It means that an evaluation should consider the quality of work, the decisions made, the challenges involved and the value created alongside the final result.

 

The nature of meaningful performance also differs across functions. Customer support cannot be evaluated only by the number of tickets closed, just as HR cannot be assessed only by the number of vacancies filled. The quality of resolutions, employee experience and longer-term outcomes matter too.

 

The Challenge of Evaluating Fairly

While employees expect recognition for their efforts, managers have the responsibility of making decisions that are fair, consistent and aligned with organisational priorities. This is not always straightforward.

 

A manager may be evaluating employees with very different roles, levels of responsibility and working conditions. Some contributions are immediately visible through sales figures or project outcomes, while others happen behind the scenes and are harder to quantify.

 

There is also the possibility of unconscious bias. An employee who regularly interacts with senior leadership may receive greater visibility than someone whose contribution is equally important but less apparent. Managers may also unintentionally give more weight to recent achievements or setbacks than to an employee’s performance across the entire review period.

 

For instance, an employee who has delivered consistently throughout the year may have one difficult month just before the appraisal. If that recent setback dominates the evaluation, it can overshadow months of reliable work. The reverse can also happen, where a strong finish receives more attention than recurring performance issues earlier in the year.

 

These situations can influence how performance is perceived, even when they do not reflect the complete picture.

 

I believe this is where managerial judgement becomes important. Managers need to look beyond the final numbers, understand the work behind them and question their own assessments. Employees should be evaluated against relevant expectations rather than personal preferences or visibility.

 

At the same time, fairness does not mean treating every employee identically. Different roles require different measures of success. What matters is that the criteria are clear, relevant and applied consistently.

 

Performance Is a Two-Way Responsibility

An appraisal should not be a process in which managers evaluate and employees simply accept the outcome. Employees also have a responsibility to understand their goals, communicate challenges, seek feedback and take ownership of their development.

 

However, this becomes difficult when expectations are unclear or feedback is limited to the appraisal meeting.

 

Consider an employee who hears for the first time during their annual review that their work has not been meeting expectations. They may have spent months believing they were on the right track, only to discover that their manager had concerns that were never discussed earlier.

 

This is a missed opportunity for both sides. The employee has lost the chance to correct course, while the manager has allowed a performance gap to continue without addressing it.

 

Managers need to create an environment where employees can discuss progress, raise concerns and understand where they need to improve. Employees, in turn, should feel comfortable asking questions, seeking clarity and taking responsibility for addressing feedback.

 

This exchange becomes particularly important when business priorities change. An employee who begins the year working towards one set of objectives may be asked to take on a different responsibility midway through the year. If their appraisal continues to focus only on their original targets, the evaluation may no longer reflect the work they were actually expected to do.

 

Managers must therefore revisit goals when circumstances change and ensure that employees understand how their performance will be assessed.

 

Moving Beyond the Annual Appraisal

Annual appraisals continue to serve an important purpose. They provide a formal opportunity to review performance, support compensation decisions, identify development needs and discuss career progression. I do not believe organisations need to abandon them.

 

However, an annual review cannot replace regular conversations between managers and employees.

 

When feedback is given throughout the year, employees have an opportunity to improve while there is still time to make a difference. Managers can clarify expectations, address performance gaps early and recognise good work without waiting for a formal review cycle.

 

Organisations should also encourage employees to participate in the appraisal process through self-assessments. These provide an opportunity for individuals to reflect on their achievements, challenges and learning. They may also bring forward contributions that managers have not directly observed.

 

Technology can further support this process by helping organisations track goals, monitor progress and identify patterns across teams. However, data should inform decisions, not replace the judgement required to understand individual circumstances. A performance dashboard may show whether a target was achieved, but it cannot always explain the challenges behind the result or the contribution an employee made beyond the numbers.

 

Ultimately, performance management needs both structure and conversation. One provides consistency; the other provides context.

 

Measuring Performance Should Help People Grow

The purpose of a performance appraisal should extend beyond assigning ratings or determining increments. It should help organisations understand the contribution of their people while giving employees clarity about their strengths, development areas and future opportunities.

 

For employers, this means maintaining accountability while recognising the different ways in which employees create value. For managers, it means approaching evaluations with preparation, objectivity and an understanding of the work being assessed. For employees, it means taking an active role in their performance and development rather than viewing appraisal as an outcome they have no influence over.

 

A good appraisal process should be able to answer three questions: What did the employee contribute? What could they have done better? And what support or opportunities will help them progress?

 

If an appraisal ends with a rating but leaves these questions unanswered, the organisation may have completed its evaluation process without achieving its real purpose.

 

I believe performance should be measured, but it should never be reduced to a number. The real value of an appraisal lies in how well it helps an organisation recognise contribution, address gaps and create the conditions for people to perform better. 

 

For further insights into the evolving workplace paradigm, visit  

JOIN OUR WHATSAPP CHANEL     

Radhika Raichura

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.